| Title | The Rise and Fall of the US Mortgage and Credit Markets: A Comprehensive Analysis of the Market Meltdown |
| Author | James R. Barth |
| Publisher | Wiley |
| Year | 2009 |
| Edition | 1st |
| Language | English |
| Pages | 562 |
| ISBN | 9780470477243 |
| Genre | Finance, Economics |
| Size | 7.13 MB |
| Extension |
Summary
The Rise and Fall of the US Mortgage and Credit Markets is a rigorous post-mortem of the 2008 financial cataclysm, authored by James R. Barth in collaboration with a team of economists from the Milken Institute. Published by Wiley in 2009, the book emerged as one of the earliest comprehensive attempts to systematically document the mechanics of the mortgage meltdown while the crisis was still unfolding. Barth, a veteran financial economist who had previously served as chief economist for federal banking regulators under two presidents, brought an insider’s understanding of regulatory architecture to a subject that many contemporaneous accounts treated with either partisan outrage or bewildering technical opacity [citation:3][citation:4].
The book’s analytical core rests on an exhaustive dataset—over 200 graphs and 100 tables according to contemporaneous reviews—that traces the contagion from subprime loan origination through securitization channels and into the global credit system [citation:5]. Barth dissects the failure points with clinical precision: the erosion of underwriting standards, the perverse incentives embedded in the originate-to-distribute model, the capital arbitrage facilitated by off-balance-sheet vehicles, and the complacency of rating agencies that stamped complex mortgage-backed securities with investment-grade ratings. He devotes substantial attention to the government-sponsored enterprises Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, examining how their hybrid public-private status encouraged excessive risk-taking while regulators looked the other way [citation:4][citation:9].
For readers seeking to understand the policy response, the book provides a sobering assessment of the government’s interventions up to the time of publication. Barth argues that the emergency measures—the Troubled Asset Relief Program, the Federal Reserve’s liquidity facilities, and the conservatorship of the GSEs—were largely reactive and piecemeal rather than rooted in a coherent reform framework. He contends that the deeper structural issues, particularly the fragmented system of bank supervision and the moral hazard embedded in deposit insurance and too-big-to-fail guarantees, remained substantially unaddressed even as trillions of dollars in public funds were deployed [citation:4][citation:9]. The concluding chapters outline principles for regulatory reform, emphasizing the need for consolidated supervision, higher capital requirements, and a resolution mechanism for systemically important institutions.
The book is unambiguously written for a professional and academic audience. A 125-page statistical appendix, a glossary of financial terminology, and extensive endnotes make it a formidable reference work rather than a casual read. A reviewer for CHOICE magazine described the volume as “almost overwhelming” in its density but concluded that “for those who can stay awake and pay attention, this book provides unmatched analyses” of the crisis, awarding it an Essential rating . Students of finance and economics will find the data invaluable; policymakers will find the reform proposals substantive; general readers seeking a narrative account of the crisis would be better served elsewhere, though the introductory chapters do provide a clear chronological overview suitable for the determined layperson.
The book’s enduring value lies in its refusal to reduce the crisis to a single villain. Barth distributes responsibility across borrowers, lenders, securitizers, rating agencies, regulators, and the GSEs, while acknowledging the role of macroeconomic factors such as low interest rates and global savings imbalances. This nuanced, evidence-heavy approach has earned the book a reputation as a reliable reference for scholars seeking to understand not merely what happened, but precisely how the institutional failures interconnected. For anyone studying the regulatory architecture that emerged from the crisis—Dodd-Frank, Basel III, and the ongoing debates over GSE reform—Barth’s analysis provides essential context on the problems those reforms were designed to solve [citation:5].
Key Features
- Presents over 200 graphs and 100 tables that document the mortgage crisis with granular statistical detail.
- Includes a 125-page data appendix, a glossary of financial terms, and extensive endnotes for further research.
- Analyzes the roles of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac as hybrid public-private entities that distorted market incentives.
- Examines the originate-to-distribute model and how securitization severed the link between lender and borrower risk.
- Critiques the rating agencies’ failure to accurately assess mortgage-backed securities and collateralized debt obligations.
- Documents the government’s emergency interventions, including TARP and GSE conservatorship, and assesses their limitations.
- Argues that piecemeal regulatory fixes leave the financial system vulnerable to future crises of similar origin.
- Written by a former chief economist of the Federal Home Loan Bank Board and Office of Thrift Supervision.
- Draws on the collective research of the Milken Institute’s economics team, including contributions from Tong Li, Glenn Yago, and Wenling Lu.
- Received an Essential rating from CHOICE magazine, the reviewing journal of the American Library Association.
- Provides a chronological narrative of the crisis from the housing boom through the credit freeze and into the early recovery period.
- Explores how leverage, accounting practices, and compensation structures amplified risk throughout the financial sector.
- Offers policy recommendations centered on consolidated supervision, capital adequacy, and resolution authority.
About the Author
James R. Barth was a Senior Fellow at the Milken Institute and the Lowder Eminent Scholar in Finance at Auburn University’s Harbert College of Business [citation:3][citation:4]. He held the Auburn position from 1989 until his death in 2023, a tenure spanning more than three decades during which he became one of the most frequently cited scholars on banking regulation and financial institutions . Barth’s research focused on domestic and global financial institutions and capital markets, with particular emphasis on regulatory policy and its unintended consequences.
His government service included appointments by Presidents Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush as chief economist of the Federal Home Loan Bank Board and later of the Office of Thrift Supervision [citation:3][citation:4]. This experience placed him at the center of the savings and loan crisis, an earlier financial debacle that informed his later analysis of the mortgage meltdown. Barth authored or edited numerous books, including The Great Savings and Loan Debacle, The Reform of Federal Deposit Insurance, and Rethinking Bank Regulation: Till Angels Govern. He also led an international team advising the People’s Bank of China on banking reform and participated in U.S. State Department speaker programs in China, India, Russia, and Egypt [citation:9].
Beyond his academic and advisory work, Barth was a prolific commentator whose views appeared in the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, and broadcast programs including The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer and CNBC’s Closing Bell [citation:3]. He co-edited the Journal of Financial Economic Policy and served on numerous editorial boards. His death in 2023 prompted tributes from colleagues who described him as a mentor and a tireless advocate for evidence-based financial policy . The Rise and Fall of the US Mortgage and Credit Markets stands as a testament to his conviction that financial crises are not acts of nature but consequences of identifiable policy choices and institutional failures.
Related Books
- The Big Short — Michael Lewis
- Too Big to Fail — Andrew Ross Sorkin
- The Great Savings and Loan Debacle — James R. Barth
- Rethinking Bank Regulation: Till Angels Govern — James R. Barth, Gerard Caprio Jr., Ross Levine
- Fool’s Gold — Gillian Tett
- The Subprime Solution — Robert J. Shiller
- Financial Shock — Mark Zandi
Ads
FAQ
Q : Who else contributed to this book besides James Barth?
R : The book was a collaborative effort involving a team of economists at the Milken Institute. While Barth is listed as the primary author, the title page and library records credit Tong Li, Glenn Yago, Wenling Lu, and Triphon Phumiwasana as co-authors or contributors [citation:2]. This collective authorship reflects the Milken Institute’s institutional research project on the mortgage crisis, which involved extensive data collection and analysis by multiple researchers under Barth’s direction.
Q : Is the book’s analysis still relevant given that it was published in 2009?
R : The book’s diagnostic sections remain highly relevant because they document the structural flaws that caused the crisis with primary-source data and contemporaneous analysis. The policy recommendations and the assessment of early government interventions are necessarily dated—the book was completed before Dodd-Frank, before the full scope of foreclosures became clear, and before the subsequent eurozone crisis. However, for understanding the root causes and the initial policy responses, the book’s proximity to events is an advantage rather than a limitation. Later scholarship has built upon the foundation that Barth and his team laid [citation:5].
Q : What is the significance of the 125-page appendix?
R : The appendix is arguably the book’s most distinctive feature. It contains the raw statistical material—tables, charts, and data series—that underpin the analytical chapters. For researchers, this appendix serves as a ready reference for key indicators of the housing bubble and credit expansion: origination volumes by loan type, delinquency rates, home price indices, leverage ratios at major financial institutions, and more. A reviewer noted that the book’s value lies substantially in this data compilation, which allows readers to trace the crisis’s progression quantitatively rather than relying on narrative alone [citation:5].
Q : How does Barth分配 responsibility for the crisis?
R : Barth resists monocausal explanations. He identifies failures at multiple levels: borrowers who took on unsustainable debt, lenders who abandoned underwriting standards, securitizers who packaged and sold risky loans without retaining skin in the game, rating agencies that mispriced risk, and regulators who failed to supervise the shadow banking system. He also assigns significant responsibility to the government-sponsored enterprises, arguing that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s implicit government backing allowed them to operate with inadequate capital while pursuing aggressive growth targets. The book’s chapter titles reflect this distributed accountability, asking “What Went Wrong?” with origination practices, with the GSEs, with tax benefits for homeownership, and with the “greed factor” [citation:4][citation:9].
Q : Does the book explain what subprime mortgages are for a non-specialist reader?
R : Yes. Barth devotes early chapters to defining subprime mortgages, identifying who subprime borrowers were, and explaining how securitization transformed the mortgage market. He describes in straightforward terms how loans were pooled into securities, tranched by risk, and sold to investors with varying appetites for yield. The book assumes no prior technical expertise in structured finance, though readers without any background in economics may still find the density of data challenging. The glossary and the clear prose in the introductory chapters make the core concepts accessible to a motivated general reader [citation:9].
Q : What reforms does Barth recommend?
R : The concluding chapter outlines principles rather than a detailed legislative blueprint. Barth emphasizes the need for consolidated supervision of financial institutions that operate across multiple regulatory jurisdictions, higher and more consistent capital requirements, and a resolution mechanism for systemically important non-bank institutions. He is skeptical of piecemeal fixes that address symptoms without altering the underlying incentive structures. His broader argument is that regulation must be designed with an awareness of how market participants will adapt to rules—a lesson drawn from his earlier work on the savings and loan crisis [citation:4][citation:9].
Q : Where can I find the book’s data in a more current form?
R : The Federal Reserve’s FRED database, the FDIC’s quarterly banking profile, and the FHFA’s house price index all provide updated versions of many series that Barth uses. For academic researchers, the book’s endnotes point to original sources including regulatory filings, industry reports, and academic papers. The Milken Institute has also continued to publish research on housing finance and financial regulation, though Barth’s later work shifted toward international banking comparisons and the Chinese financial system.
Enregistrer un commentaire
Thanks for comment